Saving for retirement and planning for senior living is a long-term process for many people. Depending on individual spending and saving habits, funds are often allocated into distinct “buckets” for different goals. Mental accounting — the tendency to treat money differently depending on its source and intended use — strongly influences financial choices, including decisions about senior living and long-term care.
Payment method also affects spending behavior. For example, cash and credit cards feel different psychologically. Credit cards separate the act of buying from the act of paying: you make a purchase now and settle the bill later, while cash requires an immediate, tangible exchange.
That separation reduces perceived loss. A $50 service you charged to a card feels smaller when it appears on a larger monthly statement than when you hand over a $50 bill at the point of sale. When the full credit card bill arrives, that single $50 charge is easier to rationalize. The immediate sting of parting with cash can make people choose the cheaper option more often than when they use credit.
>> Related: Many People Underestimate Their Future Cost of Care
The pain of paying truly smarts
“Willingness to pay” (WTP) and the “pain of paying” describe how emotionally costly spending money can feel. Research shows that spending really does create an unpleasant response for many people.
In a 2001 experiment, MIT researchers compared participants’ WTP for sporting event tickets when restricted to paying by cash versus credit card. Those required to use credit cards were willing to pay nearly twice as much as those who had to use cash. In other words, credit-card payers displayed a far higher willingness to pay than cash payers.
This result reflects the pain of paying: an emotional discomfort tied to parting with money. Neuroscientific studies have gone further, showing that anticipating a payment activates brain regions associated with processing pain. While this is not physical pain in the clinical sense, it is a real affective response that can reduce people’s willingness to spend.
>> Related: The Cost of a CCRC vs. the Value to Residents
Reducing the pain of paying
The intensity of the pain of paying changes with the payment method and timing. Tuning these factors can improve financial outcomes and satisfaction.
For example, research comparing pre-paid monthly fees to pay-as-you-go pricing for a health club found that people reported greater satisfaction with a fixed monthly payment than with hourly charges. Pre-paying removes repeated reminders of cost and reduces the cumulative sting of frequent payments. This effect can be reinforced if the recurring payment is automated or charged to a card, further decreasing loss aversion.
>> Related: What’s the True Cost of Staying in the Home?
Senior living community costs can hurt
These psychological dynamics are important when evaluating the affordability of senior living communities, including continuing care retirement communities (CCRCs) or life plan communities.
Many CCRCs require an entry or entrance fee, which can be a significant up-front payment. Residents typically also pay a monthly service fee that covers the residence, utilities, property taxes, and at least one meal per day, with additional services and amenities often included. Depending on the contract, the monthly fee may be fixed or it may change if higher levels of care are needed later.
Often, seniors use proceeds from a home sale to cover the entry fee. That large, one-time outlay can produce substantial pain of paying. By contrast, the monthly service fee is usually mentally categorized as a routine housing expense, and—if paid automatically—may feel less painful since the outflow is less visible, much like credit-card charges on a monthly statement.
>> Related: “I’m Not Ready Yet” Part 2: The Cost of Peace of Mind
Reducing the pain of paying for a CCRC
There are strategies and contract features that can lessen the psychological burden of paying for a CCRC.
First, some contracts offer a refundable portion of the entry fee, meaning you or your heirs may recover some or most of the initial payment. Knowing that part of the fee is refundable can ease the immediate sting of a large expenditure.
Second, depending on the agreement, portions of the entry fee and ongoing monthly charges may qualify as pre-paid medical expenses, which in some cases are treated as deductible medical costs for tax purposes. If you itemize and your medical expenses exceed the applicable threshold of your adjusted gross income, you may be able to deduct qualifying amounts. Consult your tax advisor for specifics, but this potential tax treatment can reduce the net cost and associated pain of paying.
>> Related: Understanding Tax Deductions for CCRC Residents
Pre-paying for potential long-term care needs
Although senior living and CCRCs can be costly, it helps to remember what you receive in return. Similar to pre-paid membership models that increase satisfaction, a CCRC effectively pre-pays for future access to various levels of care. That pre-payment can lessen loss aversion compared with an unpredictable, pay-as-you-go approach to long-term care.
By contrast, remaining at home can leave individuals vulnerable to unexpected care costs after a health crisis. Those unplanned expenses—both financial and emotional—can be more painful than the planned, pre-paid model offered by many CCRCs.