I recently read a PBS Newshour piece titled “How to Stay Out of a Nursing Home and Age Independently,” which summarized a Swedish study identifying factors that predict whether older adults can continue living independently into their 80s. The study’s lead author, geriatrician Kristin Franzon, emphasized that “preserved independence is highly valued by very old individuals,” and her team looked for measurable behaviors that increase the chances of remaining in one’s own home instead of needing institutional care. Not surprisingly, their findings highlighted an active lifestyle, not smoking, and following a Mediterranean-style diet as important contributors to longer independent living.
>> Related: Live to 100 With These Blue Zone Diet Tips
Healthy habits clearly improve the odds of staying well longer and may reduce the need for assistance with daily living. That said, the Newshour article prompted me to reflect on how we talk about seniors’ desire to “age independently” and remain at home.
An inaccurate label
Many surveys—AARP among them—report that roughly 90 percent of older adults want to stay in their homes as they age. That statistic has fed the widespread belief that living at home equals independence while moving to a retirement community means losing independence. For many, “aging in place” is seen as the most comfortable, convenient, and economical option.
But the phrase “age independently” can be misleading. Living in one’s own home does not automatically mean a person is independent. Where someone lives does not determine whether they are dependent or independent; a person can be dependent in any setting.
For example, a senior who chooses to stay in their home may initially require no help with activities of daily living (ADLs) such as preparing food, bathing, or dressing—and that situation might remain unchanged for years.
Or it may change.
If health declines, that same person may require increasing levels of assistance or develop complex care needs. Who will provide that help? Will an adult child be willing and able to take on caregiving responsibilities? Will the family hire in-home care, and how much will that cost? Will home modifications be needed to accommodate mobility aids or a wheelchair? These are practical questions families should discuss when a senior plans to remain at home long term. They also raise an important point: at what moment does “living independently” stop being real independence?
>> Related: 8 Questions to Consider Before You Decide to Age in Place
Another concern is social isolation. As health or mobility decline, or after the loss of a spouse or close friends, seniors who live alone at home often become isolated. A Congressional report called senior loneliness—a condition affecting millions—a “silent killer,” noting its serious mental and physical consequences and the association with premature death.
>> The Senior Loneliness Epidemic & Solutions to “Cure” It
Staying at home can offer familiarity and sometimes lower cost, but it also brings potential downsides that should be weighed alongside the benefits.
Aging independently, with assistance
What about life in a continuing care retirement community (CCRC) or other senior living community? Some people worry that moving into a CCRC means admitting they are “old” and surrendering independence. Many older adults feel younger and healthier than previous generations and resist the idea of moving to a community filled with peers.
CCRCs and other senior communities are not the right fit for everyone—reasons can include personal preference, cost, or a desire to remain in a longtime home. However, CCRCs often help residents remain independent longer.
CCRCs provide amenities and services that support daily living and, importantly, they offer a continuum of care: progressive levels of medical and personal support available as needs change. Most residents start in independent living, and if health issues arise, the same community can provide assistance with ADLs, assisted living services, or skilled nursing care without the need to relocate.
>> Learn all about CCRCs here.
Because CCRCs handle caregiving needs on-site, families often avoid the stress of coordinating care for an aging relative. Visits become focused on quality time rather than managing medical logistics—an outcome that many people consider the essence of true independence.
Taking charge of your future
Accepting help when it becomes necessary does not mean giving up. CCRCs can tailor the level of assistance to each resident’s needs—offering housekeeping, help with bathing and dressing, or, when required, full-time nursing care. Thinking through options and planning ahead can reveal choices that preserve autonomy and quality of life.
I encourage people to evaluate all senior living possibilities rather than assuming that staying in a longtime home is the only path to independence. For many, a CCRC or similar community delivers the kind of supported independence that makes life safer, more social, and more enjoyable.